Apple drops ‘available now’ from Apple Intelligence page - The Verge

Apple's "Stop Think Change" Campaign Under Fire by NAD

In a recent decision, the National Advertising Division (NAD), a part of the Council of Better Business Bureaus (CBBB), recommended that Apple modify or discontinue its "Stop Think Change" campaign. This campaign, which debuted in 2021, aimed to promote Apple's iPhones as a means to help people stop using their previous phones and change their lives for the better.

The NAD received several complaints about the campaign, with some advertisers alleging that it was misleading and deceptive. In response to these concerns, the NAD conducted an investigation into Apple's claims, examining whether the ads were substantiated by evidence.

The Issues Raised

Several issues were raised during the investigation, including:

• Misleading comparisons: Some complainants argued that Apple's ads made unsubstantiated claims about the capabilities and performance of its iPhones compared to their competitors.
• Overemphasis on switching costs: The NAD noted that some ads implied that using an iPhone would save consumers time and money, which was not substantiated by evidence.
• Failure to disclose trade-offs: Apple's ads suggested that switching to an iPhone would be a positive experience for consumers, without disclosing potential drawbacks such as increased costs or environmental impact.

NAD Recommendation

In its report, the NAD concluded that while some of Apple's claims were unsubstantiated, others were based on reasonable inferences from the evidence. However, the NAD recommended that Apple modify or discontinue certain claims to avoid misleading consumers.

The recommendation suggests that Apple should:

• Provide clear and conspicuous disclosures about potential drawbacks or trade-offs associated with switching to an iPhone.
• Avoid making unsubstantiated claims about the capabilities or performance of its iPhones compared to competitors.
• Use more transparent language when describing the benefits of using an iPhone, avoiding exaggerated or misleading statements.

Implications for Apple

The NAD's recommendation has significant implications for Apple's marketing strategy. To avoid further action by regulatory bodies, Apple must:

• Revise its advertising claims to be more accurate and substantiated.
• Ensure that all ads are clear and transparent about potential drawbacks or trade-offs associated with using an iPhone.
• Be more cautious in making comparisons between its iPhones and those of competitors.

Conclusion

The NAD's recommendation serves as a reminder for advertisers, including Apple, to prioritize transparency and accuracy in their marketing claims. By revising its advertising strategy to meet the NAD's recommendations, Apple can help maintain consumer trust and avoid further regulatory action.

Ultimately, this decision highlights the importance of accountability in advertising and the need for companies to be mindful of the impact their marketing efforts may have on consumers.